| Skip Bouchard | 160lbs | #95 | (77-49) |
| Pete "KTFO" Colon | 275lbs | #343 | (60-39) |
| Luka Lazarev | 224lbs | #391 | (60-46) |
| Mac "Super Punchout" Nash | 196lbs | #457 | (58-41) |
| Karl "Rowdy" Rowly | 163lbs | #479 | (57-40) |
| Rudy "The Finisher" Bouchard | 196lbs | #1672 | (68-53) |
| Sonny Mitchell | 180lbs | #2161 | (33-30) |
| Matthew "The Midcarder" Jenkins | 155lbs | #2241 | (45-44) |
| Roger Wright | 245lbs | #2605 | (36-37) |
| George "Cousin" Fournier | 248lbs | #2631 | (11-14) |
| Luis "Mexican Brit" Torres | 169lbs | #2678 | (28-23) |
| AJ Ouellet | 172lbs | #2713 | (13-13) |
| Ted Davis | 157lbs | #2827 | (24-23) |
| Curt "Makes You Tremble" Tremblay | 178lbs | #2909 | (27-26) |
| Pete Grenier | 147lbs | #3076 | (63-55) |
| Bart Jenkins | 194lbs | #3179 | (12-11) |
| Justin Hamilton | 182lbs | #3401 | (17-21) |
| Preston Russell | 254lbs | #3465 | (13-17) |
| Sidney "Diamond in the Rough" Coleman | 163lbs | #4525 | (14-22) |
| Race "Card" Landry | 155lbs | #4595 | (2-2) |
| Hack "Away" Hughes | 178lbs | #4796 | (52-52) |
| Vernon Baker | 178lbs | #5176 | (5-8) |
| Robert Gray | 156lbs | #5325 | (19-23) |
| Greg Morris | 183lbs | #7040 | (25-27) |
| Shelton Adams | 171lbs | #7079 | (9-19) |
| Neil Hall | 172lbs | #7192 | (21-25) |
| Urie Popov | 165lbs | #7698 | (11-16) |
| Guy Cherry | 147lbs | #7753 | (19-25) |
| Wes "Loves to" 69 | 177lbs | #8099 | (7-12) |
| Earl Wright | 168lbs | #8158 | (1-3) |
| Nelson "Narly" Nash | 237lbs | #8412 | (13-22) |
| Eric Savard | 238lbs | #8823 | (15-21) |
| Floyd Lundy | 204lbs | #8861 | (0-7) |
| Hawk "The Predator" Kelly | 235lbs | #9864 | (3-16) |
| Shane "The Coward" Howard | 167lbs | #9882 | (7-11) |
| Harold Parker | 210lbs | #9978 | (3-20) |
| Buddy "My Buddy" Twitty | 188lbs | #10316 | (1-8) |
| Preston Nash | 173lbs | #10808 | (1-5) |
| Nate "The Great" Belanger | 181lbs | #11109 | (0-2) |
| Teddy Perry | 152lbs | #11155 | (6-15) |
| Branden Elkins | 158lbs | #11211 | (7-21) |
| Richard Carter | 190lbs | #11606 | (2-4) |
| Seth Walker | 189lbs | #11675 | (6-9) |
| Damian Barnes | 152lbs | #11692 | (3-9) |
| Kenny "Too Much Nintendo" 64 | 196lbs | #11923 | (3-7) |
| Lee "roy" Brown | 148lbs | #12283 | (0-2) |
| Colt "45" Nadeau | 154lbs | #12560 | (0-2) |
| Kirk Bernier | 166lbs | #12733 | (16-19) |
| Cru Evans | 210lbs | #13288 | (1-6) |
